By Penny Schwartz
Memorial plaques bearing the names of Poles killed for rescuing Jews line the pathway leading to a small, austere structure built into a hillside in Markowa, a rural village in south-eastern Poland.
In the centre courtyard, a large slab is inscribed to the memory of Jewish victims of the Holocaust.
The quiet, reflective space sets the stage for the haunting story that unfolds within the walls of the building, a museum that commemorates Józef and Wiktoria Ulma, local farmers who sacrificed their lives and those of their six young children for sheltering eight Jews during the Nazi occupation.
Opened about two years ago, but still little known among Jews worldwide, the Ulma Family Museum of Poles Saving Jews in the Second World War is the first national museum to honour Poles who aided Jews during the Holocaust.
In 1995, Józef and Wiktoria Ulma were posthumously named Righteous Among the Nations by Jerusalem’s Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial, which said their story “has become a symbol of Polish sacrifice and martyrdom during the German occupation”.
More than 6,800 Poles have been recognised for risking their lives to save Jews, the largest number from any individual country.
The museum’s permanent exhibit seeks to shed light on the Polish righteous and those who assisted Jews during the Holocaust.
There are similar institutions dedicated to righteous gentiles in France and Germany.
But beyond the historical chronicle, says director Anna Stróz, the Markowa museum offers “an important universal message about being human in inhuman times”.
Beginning in the autumn of 1942, during the Nazi occupation of Poland and following round-ups and killings of Jews in the region, the Ulmas offered shelter to eight Jews at their farmhouse in Markowa: Saul Goldman of nearby Lancut and his four sons, and Genia Grünfeld, her sister Lea Didner and Didner’s daughter, all of Markowa.
The group hid in the family’s attic for about a year and a half. Goldman, a cattle dealer, and his sons helped the Ulmas with farm chores.
In the early morning of March 24, 1944, the Ulma farmhouse was raided by Nazi officers and members of the Blue Police, the police forces in German-occupied Poland.
The Ulmas were probably ratted out by Wlodzimierz Les, a local policeman who knew the Goldmans from Lancut.
The Jews in hiding were murdered first. Next the Nazis killed Józef and Wiktoria, who was seven months pregnant. The commanding officer, Lt Eilert Dieken, then ordered the murder of the six Ulma children.
“We will spare you the trouble in the village,” Dieken remarked, according to one of the policemen present.
Under Nazi rule, harbouring Jews was an offence punishable by immediate execution. Les was shot by Polish underground soldiers a few months after the Ulmas’ massacre.
Some 90,000 people have visited the museum since it opened in March, 2016, according to museum officials.
This summer, the Polish Cultural Institute New York is featuring the Ulmas’ story in an exhibition on the fence outside the Polish Consulate in Manhattan.
It opened in late June and presents the history of the Ulma family during the Second World War.
In Markowa, the museum’s permanent exhibit draws on historical records, original documents and artifacts from the Ulma family and local residents, as well as personal testimonies.
Explanatory information is in Polish, English and Hebrew. The museum has a stunning collection of photographs taken by Józef Ulma, an amateur photographer, who chronicled daily life in the area.
Before the war, approximately 120 Jews lived in Markowa. Thanks in part to the efforts of eight Polish families, some 21 Jews are known to have survived.
Visitors can “uncover” photographs of Jewish hiding places by tilting back small steel covers.
One tells of the rescue efforts of Jan and Helena Cwynar, who sheltered Abraham Segal. Now 86 and living in Israel, Segal is the only remaining Jewish survivor from Markowa.
Local Poles who denounced their neighbours for sheltering Jews are also part of the exhibition.
One item features handwritten testimony by Markowa’s mayor from the post-war trial of a policeman involved in the Ulma farm raid.
The exhibit includes testimony by local Poles in post-war trials about neighbours who attacked farms belonging to those hiding Jews.
Poignantly, the museum features a one-to-one scale re-creation of the interior of the Ulmas’ modest home.
Furniture, a workbench and other objects provide a palpable feel of their simple lives.
Yet Józef’s farming interests and techniques were cutting edge for the time, and he was a beekeeper, bred silkworms and grew fruit trees.
Books and photographs suggest that Józef was well-read and reveal a rural family surprisingly engaged in the wider world beyond daily challenges of farm life.
“By today’s standards, he [Józef Ulma] was a local opinion leader,” Polish President Andrzej Duda said at the museum’s opening ceremony.
While the courage and heroism of the Ulma family is widely acknowledged, some Holocaust scholars have cautioned that the exhibition’s focus on rescuers may leave visitors with the erroneous impression that it was common for Poles to assist their Jewish neighbours.
In fact, it was not, and even in cases where Poles risked their lives to save Jews they had to fear their Polish neighbours betraying them. (The Ulma Museum does note clearly that only some Poles saved Jews).
The scholars’ concern comes amid the Polish parliament’s passage last year of a law that would have criminalised ascribing blame to the Polish state or Polish nation for Nazi crimes against Jews or suggesting that Poland bears some complicity for the Holocaust.
At the request of Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki, lawmakers voted this week to moderate the law, making it a civil and not a criminal offence. The law is also being reviewed by Poland’s constitutional court.
Stróz said her museum is careful to present the full spectrum of attitudes and negative behaviour that was present during the period.
Next year, she said, the museum plans to hold an international educational conference “to confront the different points of view and different ways of narration”.
American-born Rabbi Michael Schudrich, the chief rabbi of Poland, called the Ulma Family Museum a worthy endeavour.
He said he was satisfied with the way it addresses difficult issues in local Polish-Jewish relations, and that it does not claim to be a museum about the broader history of the Holocaust.
“The museum was created to respect and talk about the righteous gentiles,” Schudrich said. “When God created human beings, he wanted us to be like the righteous.”
Stróz, an art historian whose doctoral studies at Catholic University in Lublin focused on places of remembrance, has ambitious plans for the museum.
She wants to bolster programming, broaden the museum’s reach of visitors and hire more staff.
Most urgently, however, she wants to continue the museum’s mission of acquiring personal testimonies from rescuers and those who were rescued.
“It is the greatest challenge for us today,” Stróz said, “all the more so because we are aware of our responsibility and the inexorable passage of time.”
If you have a story or an issue you want us to cover, let us know - in complete confidence - by contacting email@example.com, 0161-741 2631 or via Facebook / Twitter